Something has changed
"I used to love this base. But they must have changed the formula. Now it is rubbery and melts differently."
Crafter's Choice






Crafter's Choice
Overall rating: 4.8461537 / 5 from 403 reviews.
This detergent-free baby buttermilk melt and pour soap base is praised for its creamy texture, excellent lather, and gentle effect on the skin. Customers appreciate its vibrant color, wonderful scent, and the ability to add essential oils for a silky feel. The base is also noted for its even melting and hardening properties.
Review topics: ["color","results","quality","scent","feel","look","packaging","problems","base","texture","water","works","price","buy","use","used","packages","packaged","soap","lather","skin","melts","bar","oil","fragrance","sweat","ingredients","buttermilk","moisturizing","seller"].
"I used to love this base. But they must have changed the formula. Now it is rubbery and melts differently."
"Great M/P soap in convenient size. Holds essential oil scent well too. I appreciate that this blend keeps unhealthy chemicals to a minimum."
"I really wanted to love this M&P Buttermilk soap, but it just is below average. Even after letting it sit once poured in a rectangular mold after 48 hours it is still so soft you can almost bend it like rubber. Sure it feels wonderful on your skin, but with this soap being so very soft I don't believe customers are going to like it. First I poured it by itself, results soft after 48 hours, then I did 1/2 buttermilk and 1/2 goat milk, and the bar was still so soft after 48 hours. I just don't get it, all the other CS soaps are superior that I have tried, but this is just a real disappointment."
"I can never complain about your profit or shipping. You are the best! Thank you"
"First time ordering this M&P and loved working with it. Is a little soft, but I'm sure this is the additions to the soap. Love the work time, colors well, and very creamy."
"I've tried all the bases and this is, by far, my favorite opaque base. It lathers luxuriously and I can't remember the last time that I used lotion on my hands and body. . . my skin stays nice and hydrated with this base. It takes color and fragrance well and works well as a shampoo bar, too. I have had multiple skin problems and this soap has virtually eliminated them all. . . the richest, gentlest soap I have ever used. I look forward to washing my hands now!"
Percentage Calculator
Easily convert recipes from formula weights to percentages, allowing for scalability.
lye calculator
Perfect for helping you in soap making and producing handmade soap.
fragrance calculator
Find the right amount of fragrance, flavor, or essential oils to safely add to your handmade products.
Batch Calculator
Easily convert a recipe from percentages to formula weights.